SWISSUES
PodCast
Asymmetry
0:00
-57:13

Asymmetry

The podcast is a raw and unedited recording of a live and unprepared discussion with Nadia Stoykov, Amy Jones, Aimilia Vasilakou and Stephen Fulton. The following is a short summary.

Why asymmetry as a topic

The session started from the idea that asymmetry, not balance, is the normal condition in business. Models of negotiation, competitive advantage and process flow usually assume parties of roughly equal knowledge and power playing by the same rules, and that has rarely been true. The same applies to hiring, working with colleagues, warfare and cyber conflict. The Russia-Ukraine war was cited as an example of one side assuming a conventional contest while the other played a different game.

Asymmetry in nature and systems

  • Biological bodies look symmetrical but are not: organs, brain hemispheres and muscle strength differ side to side.

  • Natural systems tend to seek balance through feedback loops, both amplifying and dampening. Large imbalances of power or aims are usually unsustainable and good for neither party.

  • Balance can come from many asymmetric parts offsetting each other, so mirror-image symmetry is not the goal.

  • Where imbalances are exploited, regulation can correct them. Mandatory salary bands in job adverts were given as an example.

Types of asymmetry in business

  • Size and market power, such as a small supplier facing a large automotive customer.

  • Differences in desire or need, where one party wants the deal far more than the other.

  • Information and knowledge.

  • Personal versus company interests: individuals on each side may be driven by bonuses, promotions or career horizons that diverge from their employer’s interests.

  • Internal asymmetry between functions, notably sales and procurement, whose goals, time horizons and attitudes to risk differ.

  • Asymmetry that shifts over time. Power swings back and forth over a long relationship as markets, technology and alternatives change.

Strategies for dealing with it

  • Pool purchasing with other small buyers to gain collective weight.

  • Learn what the other side’s representative personally needs, and trade what is cheap for you for what is valuable to them.

  • Look at total contract value, not just headline price.

  • Do not push an advantage to the point of insult, and keep the other side’s dignity.

  • Do not exploit strength in good years if you will need goodwill in bad ones. Mistreated suppliers tend to retaliate later.

  • Treat extreme dependence in either direction as a warning. One rule of thumb was that a deal should be roughly 10-30% of the supplier’s business. Much less and they will not care. Much more and they may be desperate and unable to deliver. A story of a desperate supplier who cut corners and lost its plant illustrated the latter.

  • Use long-term contracts to stop either party walking away when power shifts, though these carry their own risks.

  • Put all interests openly on the table, including the individual sales representative’s incentives.

  • Rotate people between sales and procurement to build mutual understanding.

  • Avoid penny-pinching, perverse incentives and fight-or-flight management. One account described better supplier relationships producing far larger savings than aggressive price pressure.

Points of debate

  • Mitigation versus risk-taking. One view was that procurement tries to make asymmetry symmetric by mitigating risk. The counter-view was that insuring against everything makes a product not worth buying, and that unforeseen risks arrive anyway, so agility matters more. There was also a suggestion that risk should simply be allocated to the party best placed to control it, though this fails when you have no alternative supplier.

  • Purpose. One view was that the purpose of a system is what it does, and that “purpose” is a human intent and not a property of open systems. The opposing view was that everything has a goal. The disagreement was largely put down to differing terminology.

  • Relationships versus institutional change. Good personal relationships help, but individuals move on and a new executive can tear up long-term arrangements, as with abrupt demands for discounts or shorter payment terms on existing contracts. This was compared to the erosion of the rules-based international order. Employer-employee asymmetry. A related point was that employees often invest more in a company than the company commits to them, which is another form of imbalance.

Conclusions

The broad agreement was that perfect symmetry is unrealistic and often unnecessary. The useful questions are how to recognise the asymmetry, how to avoid abusing it, and how to build relationships and contracts that survive its inevitable shifts.

Many thanks to Nadia Stoykov, Amy Jones, Aimilia Vasilakou and Stephen Fulton for their great contributions.

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?